Verse:

I said, Gracie is that you, what's it been a couple years
Hey it's 2 AM so whatchya doing here
Girl you must be breaking all those frat boy hearts
Can I walk you and your groceries to your car
We must have tried to say goodbye a time or three
I saw the sunrise in her eyes and then it dawned on me

Chorus:

I was falling for the way she was looking at me
Falling for a future I started to see
Like a penny tumbling down a wishing well
When the sun rose, I fell

Verse:

I said, How 'bout a little drive, somehow I'm not tired
Looking in her eyes I could see we both were wired
Thought she'd never fall for a home town boy like me
Til she said I was her crush since thirteen
I've never really been a lucky guy